CO129-259 - Governor Sir Robinson - 1893 [5-8] — Page 427

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

you were still dissatisfied,

and

you

asked that it might be again reconstituted

by the withdrawal of the Harbour Master, and the substitution of an unofficial member of Council in his place. Your request was based on the ground that to be of any practical value, the Committee must contain a majority of unofficial members. The Governor is at a loss to imagine by what process of reasoning you can have arrived at this astonishing conclusion. It is the more extraordinary because a subsequent letter of yours shows that you had grasped the fact that the Committee would have no power to decide anything, and that its functions were strictly limited to enquiring and recommending. It obviously follows

Page 422

21

Edit History

2026-05-27 03:16:01 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
you were still dissatisfied, and you asked that it might be again reconstituted by the withdrawal of the Harbour Master, and the substitution of an unofficial member of Council in his place. Your request was based on the ground that to be of any practical value, the Committee must contain a majority of unofficial members. The Governor is at a loss to imagine by what process of reasoning you can have arrived at this astonishing conclusion. It is the more extraordinary because a subsequent letter of yours shows that you had grasped the fact that the Committee would have no power to decide anything, and that its functions were strictly limited to enquiring and recommending. It obviously follows Page 422 21
Baseline (Original)
20 you were still dissatisfied, and you asked that it~ might be again reconstituted by the withdrawal of the. Harbour Master, and the "substitution of an unofficial member of Council in his "place"." "Your request" based on the ground that " to be of any practical ~ # was value, the Committee ~ must contain a majority of unofficial members. The Governor is at a loss to 422 21 to imagine by what ~ process of reasoning you can have arrived at this astonishing conclusion. It is the more extraordinary because a subsequent letter of yours shews that you had had grasped the fact that the Committee would have no power to decide anything, and that its functions were strictly limited to enquiring and recommending. It obviously follows }
2026-05-27 03:16:01 · Baseline
View content

20

you were still dissatisfied,

and

you

asked that it~

might be again reconstituted

by the withdrawal of the. Harbour Master, and the "substitution of an unofficial member of Council in his "place"." "Your request" based on the ground that " to be of any practical ~

#

was

value, the Committee ~

must contain a majority of unofficial members. The Governor is at a loss

to

422

21

to imagine by what ~ process of reasoning you can have arrived at this astonishing conclusion. It is the more

extraordinary

because a subsequent

letter of yours shews that you had

had grasped the fact that the Committee

would have no

power to decide anything, and that its functions were strictly limited to enquiring and recommending. It obviously

follows

}

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.